Ida Noddack and the missing elements

image - Features - Habashi - main

Source: © Fathi Habashi

Distinguished women chemists were rare in the early 20th century, but their contributions to chemistry are of great significance. Ida Noddack's scientific career centred around her intensive study of the Periodic Table, and resulted in her discovery, with husband Walter Noddack and physicist Otto Berg, of the metal rhenium, and of nuclear fission in the search for element 93. 

The search for the missing elements, which were predicted by Dmitri Mendeleev in his Periodic Table, was intensive between 1869 and 1891, especially when his prediction proved to be right after the discovery of gallium, scandium, and germanium between 1875 and 1886. These discoveries were made easier because Mendeleev had been able to describe the properties of these elements, which he called eka-boron, eka-aluminum, and eka-silicon, with a fair degree of accuracy. 

In 1901 Bohuslav Brauner in Prague predicted the existence of an element between neodymium and samarium, which was confirmed in 1914 by Henry Moseley using x-rays, and became known as element 61. In 1918 Otto Hahn and Lise Meitner in Berlin discovered protactinium and in 1923 Georg von Hevesy and Dirk Coster in Copenhagen discovered hafnium. One year earlier Niels Bohr had confirmed that lutetium is a rare earth and not a member of Group IV of the Periodic Table as was originally thought, thus proposing the search for a missing element in zirconium minerals.

Manganese, the ninth most abundant metal in Nature, was in Group 7 of Mendeleev's Table. Mendeleev had left two gaps below it, which he had marked eka-manganese (Em) and dvi-manganese (Dm) which he predicted would fill the gaps. For both eka-manganese and dvi-manganese, he was unable to predict much of their properties because they were the last two members of the Group. However, he did predict an atomic weight of 100 for Em and 190 for Dm - values that are very near to the actual values of 98 and 182.2, respectively. He also predicted that their compounds would be coloured and there would be a series of oxides corresponding to the oxides of manganese. These gaps remained unfilled for more than 50 years.

Make your lessons pop

Choose an account option to continue exploring our full range of articles and teaching resources

Register for a personal account

Free

Free access for everyone, everywhere. If you only need a few resources, start here.


What's included

  • One free teaching resource each month
  • Five free Education in Chemistry articles each month
  • Personalised email alerts and bookmarks
UK and Ireland only

Join Teach Chemistry

Free for eligible users

Free and comprehensive access for teachers and technicians at secondary schools, colleges and teacher training institutions in the UK and Ireland.


What's included

  • Unlimited access to our resources and practical videos
  • Unlimited access to Education in Chemistry articles
  • Access to our online assessments
  • Our teacher well-being toolkit and personal development resources
  • Applications for funding to support your lessons

Subscribe for extended access

£80 per year

Get unlimited articles and resources each month, plus discounts on professional development courses.


What's included

  • Unlimited access to our resources and practical videos
  • Unlimited access to Education in Chemistry articles
  • 10% off our self-led professional development courses