A rose by any other name would still be filled with pigments, use this experiment to extract dyes from plant material
You are given a collection of plant materials – leaves, petals, and so on. They are all coloured. Extract the pigments (colouring substances) from them, and decide how many different pigments you have got altogether.
- Eye protection
A range of apparatus for the commonly used paper chromatographic techniques:
- Stoppered boiling tube into which filter paper strip can be inserted
- Petri dishes
- Glass droppers
- paper clips
- pencil & ruler (measuring to mm)
Apparatus for extracting pigment from plant materials:
- Pestle and mortar
- Filter funnel
- Test tubes
- Possibly access to a centrifuge
Access to distilled water and ethanol and/or propanone.
Students are likely to want large amounts of filter paper, both for chromatography and filtration (a box per group).
The same plant materials, say 5 or 6 different types, including:
- Red-coloured leaves (eg copper beech)
- Green leaves (eg grass, spinach)
- Red cabbage or beetroot (not pickled)
- Flower petals of at least 2 different colours (eg yellow and purple)
Health, safety and technical notes
- Read our standard health and safety guidance here.
- This is an open-ended problem solving activity, so the guidance given here is necessarily incomplete.
- Propanone and ethanol are highly flammable. Keep clear of naked flames and other sources of ignition. Heating is probably not necessary, but hot water from a kettle could be made available for a water bath if requested.
- If pupils are collecting their own plant material be careful they do not collect anything dangerous such as yew or deadly nightshade.
The judges will need to run a ‘control’.
With grass, it should be possible to separate chlorophyll and xanthophyll, but you are unlikely to get more than one yellow and one green band.
With copper beech leaves it should be possible to detect a red and a green pigment – but is the green pigment the same as that in grass?
13–14 year olds are not likely to be familiar with Rf values *, but some may make qualitative judgements (eg by similarity of colour) based on ‘fair test’ comparisons.
Find out about synthetic dyes (1850s onwards).
Remember that some plants may contain more than one pigment mixed together.
Remember, too, that the same pigment may be present in more than one plant, so don’t count it twice … as long as you are sure it really is the same pigment.
Display your results in a way which will allow people to see how you arrived at your answer.
It is suggested that distilled water should NOT be used – as this is often acidic, and some pigments are indicators, this may confuse the issue.
- Experiment | PDF, Size 22.47 kb
The resources were originally published in the book In Search of Solution P. Borrows, K. Davies and R. Lewin, Royal Society of Chemistry, 1990.
This experiment was based on an idea contributed by P. Borrows.