Keep things dry as you experiment with water
Investigate what happens when different charged plastics are held near a jet of water issuing from a burette, and explain your observations.
This problem does not work well on a damp day or in a damp laboratory!
Teachers who have not used the problems before should read the section Using the problems before starting.
Familiarity with polar covalent bonding and that such bonds have charged ends; and that like charges repel and opposite charges attract. A detailed knowledge is unnecessary as students are encouraged to consult textbooks and data books during the exercise.
Data books and textbooks should be available for reference.
The following equipment and chemicals should be provided at the start of the exercise:
- two burettes;
- samples of different plastics to be charged by rubbing, plastic pens, rulers etc can also be used;
- several small lightweight watch glasses; and
- a liquid hydrocarbon.
Students can request other apparatus during the practical session and this should be issued if it is safe to use.
Discussion should focus on why water is always attracted to charged plastic; and the hydrocarbon is unaffected by charged plastic. Students will find that charged plastic always attracts the water jet because the polar water molecules are pulled round by the charged plastic so that the oppositely charged end is nearest to the plastic.
Non-polar hydrocarbon molecules are not affected by charged rods at all; it is a pity that because of its toxicity we cannot test tetrachloromethane – it is also unaffected by charged plastic.
NB Bond polarity is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for attraction. Thus tetrachloromethane is not attracted by the approach of the charged plastic as the molecule is symmetrical and the bond polarities cancel out. It is suggested that this should only be mentioned if it arises in the discussion.
During trialling the following instructions were given to students and proved to be
- Working as a group, plan the investigation and write up in note form what you are going to do. It is essential that both positively charged and negatively charged plastics are used.
- Get your method checked for safety and then carry out the practical work using water. Do plastics with opposite charges affect water in the same way?
- Now carry out the practical work using the hydrocarbon. Does the hydrocarbon behave in the same way as water?
- Discuss your results and write a brief account of what you did with explanations. Ask for advice if you are not convinced that your explanations are correct.
- Working as a group, prepare a short (ca 5-minute maximum) presentation to give to the rest of the class. If possible all group members should take part: any method of presentation (such as a blackboard, overhead projector, etc) can be used.
Outline the problem, describe what you did and explain your conclusion. After the presentation, be prepared to accept and answer questions and to discuss what you did with the rest of the class.
School Science Review, 1983, 64, 508. The liquids investigated were ethanol, propanone and water, but only the results of ethanol are given. The authors reported that it was difficult to produce an assembly that could yield consistent results.
- PDF, Size 0.18 mb
This resource is part of our Creative problem-solving in chemistry collection.