Try this practical as a small scale example of metal extraction, reducing iron(III) oxide with carbon on a match head

In this experiment, learners reduce iron(III) oxide with carbon on a match head to produce iron. The experiment provides a small-scale example of metal extraction and can be used to highlight aspects of the reactivity series.

This practical can easily be carried out individually by learners. The experiment is very quick to do provided that the apparatus and chemicals are already set out around the laboratory.

This practical is relevant for age ranges 11–14 as well as 14–16. There are separate learning objectives, follow up questions and answers for each age range.

  • Screenshots showing collection of resources

    Download this

    Download the scaffolded and unscaffolded student worksheets and teacher guidance (including answers) as MS Word and pdf, and the presentation slides as MS PowerPoint and pdf.

Learning objectives 11–14

  1. Safely investigate heating iron oxide on a match head to reduce iron.
  2. Explain why metals need to be extracted from their ores.
  3. State that the method of extraction depends on the reactivity of the metal being extracted.

Learning objectives 14–16

  1. Safely investigate heating iron oxide on a match head to reduce iron.
  2. Explain why metals need to be extracted from their ores.
  3. Explain the process of extracting metals using reduction with carbon.
  4. Identify which species are oxidised and which are reduced.

By carrying out the practical method to extract iron, learners will develop their understanding of how metals are extracted by reduction with carbon. The questions that follow consolidate their understanding of which metals can be extracted by reduction with carbon and why this is possible, and build skills in identifying which species have been oxidised and which have been reduced during the process.

Scaffolding

Two versions of the worksheet are available: scaffolded (✪) and unscaffolded (✪✪). The scaffolded sheet offers more support to allow learners to access the questions. The answers to the worksheets are also available.

You may wish to discuss as a class how to write the formula of iron(III) oxide unless learners have already covered both ionic formulas and the use of roman numerals when giving the ion charge of transition metals.

You could direct learners towards using a reactivity series to scaffold their understanding of which metals can be obtained from their ores by reduction.

Integrated instructions are provided in the lesson slides as an alternative to the full written method, designed to reduce cognitive load. Read more about improving practical work with integrated instructions.

Technician notes

Read our standard health and safety guidance and carry out a risk assessment before running any live practical.

Equipment

Apparatus

  • Safety glasses
  • Match (non-safety)
  • Tongs (crucible tongs)
  • Weighing boat (small white plastic ones are ideal)
  • Spatula
  • Bunsen burner
  • Heat resistant mat
  • Magnet (e.g. bar magnet)

Chemicals

Small amounts of the following:

  • Iron(III) oxide powder
  • Sodium carbonate powder (IRRITANT)
  • Water

Preparation

This experiment works best with non-safety/strike anywhere matches with a pinkish-read head.

You may wish to provide small amounts (a few spatula measures) of each of the powders in Petri dishes or watch classes for groups of learners to share. You can provide the water in a small beaker.

Safety and hazards

  • Wear safety glasses throughout.
  • Iron(III) oxide powder, Fe2O3(s) is FLAMMABLE. See CLEAPSS Hazcard HC055A, refer to SSERC or contact your local safety advisory body.
  • Sodium carbonate powder, Na2CO3(s) is IRRITANT. See CLEAPSS Hazcard HC095A, refer to SSERC or contact your local safety advisory body.

Method

  1. Dip the head of a match in water to moisten it.
  2. Roll the damp match head first in sodium carbonate powder, then in iron(III) oxide powder.
  3. Hold the match in a pair of tongs. Put the head of the match into a blue Bunsen flame (air-hole open). The match will flare and burn. Do not allow the match to burn more than half way along its length.
  4. Allow the match to cool for about 30 seconds.
  5. Use a spatula to crush the charred part of the match into a small plastic weighing boat.
  6. Move a magnet around under the weighing boat – some of the small particles will move around in the weighing boat following the track of the magnet. Do not dip the magnet into the particles directly unless you have first wrapped the magnet in cling film – any pieces of iron will stick to the magnet and will be difficult to clean off.

Teaching notes

A simple equation for the reaction is

Iron(III) oxide + carbon → iron + carbon dioxide

The sodium carbonate fuses easily and brings the iron oxide into close contact with the carbon.

Answers to the follow-up questions (11–14)

  1. Scaffolded and unscaffolded
    (a) Iron and oxygen
    (b) Iron oxide + carbon → iron + carbon dioxide
  2. Scaffolded
    Zinc
    Unscaffolded
    Zinc, tin, lead or copper
  3. Scaffolded
    (a) Gold
    Unscaffolded
    (a) Gold or platinum

    Scaffolded
    (b) crust, metal, profitable
    Unscaffolded
    (b) Ores are rocks that are found naturally in the Earth’s crust. They contain enough metal to make it profitable to extract.

    Scaffolded and unscaffolded
    (c) Lead sulfide + oxygen → lead oxide + sulfur dioxide

    Scaffolded and
    unscaffolded
    (d) Lead oxide + carbon → lead + carbon dioxide

Answers to the follow-up questions (14–16)

  1. Scaffolded
    (a) Fe2O3
    Unscaffolded
    (a) Iron(III) oxide + carbon → iron + carbon dioxide

    Scaffolded and unscaffolded
    (b) 2Fe2O3 + 3C → 4Fe + 3CO2

    Scaffolded
    (c) Oxidation is the gain of oxygen and oxidation is the loss of electrons
    Unscaffolded
    (c) The iron in iron(III) oxide has been reduced - it has gained electrons and lost oxygen.
    Fe3+ + 3e- → Fe

    Scaffolded
    (d) Carbon has been oxidised
          Iron has been reduced
  2. Scaffolded and unscaffolded
    Carbon is more reactive than iron, so it can displace iron from its compounds.
    Unscaffolded only
    This method would not work for any metal above carbon in the reactivity series (e.g. potassium, sodium, lithium, calcium).
  3. Scaffolded and unscaffolded
    (a) Ores are rocks that are found naturally in the Earth’s crust. They contain enough metal to make it profitable to extract.
    (b) Lead sulfide + oxygen → lead oxide + sulfur dioxide
    (c) 2PbO + C → 2Pb + CO2
    (d) Lead must be below carbon in the reactivity series as it is displaced from its compound, lead oxide, by carbon.