In this experiment, students grow crystal gardens, commenting on the size, colour and rate of growth for different crystals.
In this practical I will be:
- Setting up a practical enquiry for growing crystal gardens, ensuring that the experiment is fair.
- Reporting on the size, colour and rate of growth for the different crystals.
- Using my scientific knowledge and understanding to explain the results of the experiment.
You are an ancient Roman science-artist living in the town of Herculaneum. Whilst walking by the docks, you notice that there are salt crystals growing on the hull of a few of the boats. Not only this, but the crystals vary in size and on a particularly dirty boat, there are crystals of different colours. Like all good science-artists you decide to investigate further…
- Eye protection
- Large glass jar with lid
- Glass rod
- 8% Water glass (irritant solution)
- 2 good sized crystals of the following (see hazard symbols)
- iron(II) sulfate
- copper(II) sulfate
- calcium nitrate
- manganese(II) sulfate
- iron(II) aluminium sulfate
- potassium aluminium sulfate
- iron(III) chloride
- zinc sulfate
- (nickel sulfate demonstration only not for students)
- (cobalt chloride demonstration only not for students)
Eye protection and gloves must be worn
- Into a large glass jar pour enough water glass solution to one-third fill the jar.
- Add enough water to fill the jar to the neck of the jar.
- Mix the solution of water glass in water well using a glass rod. Take care not to spill the solution.
- Let the water glass in water solution stand for a few minutes to allow it to clear of any air bubbles.
- Using the forceps, select one large crystal of each of the solids provided and carefully drops each crystal into the water glass solution.
- Watch carefully. Describe what you see and write down the colour of the compound.
- Try not to disturb the jar while the ‘garden’ is developing. Put the lid on the jar and leave for a week.
- Wash your hands.
If time allows you could try using different dilution strength solutions of water glass and describe any differences between the results of using different dilution strengths.
A ‘garden’ can be grown from crystals.
The water glass is a solution of sodium silicate and is known as ‘water glass’. By adding more water you are forming a dilute solution of sodium silicate. When you put the crystals of metal salts into the sodium silicate solution they seem to act like seeds and grow long shoots. These long shoots are long tubes of the metal silicate and the colour depends upon the metal being used.
Teacher and Technician sheet
In this practical students will:
- Set up the practical enquiry for growing crystal gardens, ensuring that the experiment is fair.
- Report on the size, colour and rate of growth for the different crystals.
- Use their scientific knowledge and understanding to explain the results of the experiment.
Introduction for Teachers:
This is a nice experiment and an old one. Many a teacher will probably remember making a crystal garden. Yet it continues to fascinate young students. The chemistry can be a little difficult for primary level but using the garden and seeds analogy is a good one to enable a simple explanation to be attempted. For secondary level they should be able to understand some of the chemistry involved.
It can be introduced as a ‘fun’ lesson or be used at a science club session. The best discussions take place after they have done the experiment and the students can observe the growth of the crystals. The students need to be warned that the growth is not immediate and it takes about a week to see the full effects but during the lesson they may see some growth.
The jars should be moved as little as possible once the chemicals are placed into them.
It is applicable for upper primary and lower secondary dependent upon the chemical used. . It links with:
- Setting up simple practical enquiries, comparative and fair tests;
- Reporting on findings from enquiries and observations, including oral and written explanations, displays or presentations of results and conclusions;
- Using straightforward scientific evidence to answer questions or to support their findings;
- Ask questions and develop a line of enquiry based on observations of the real world, alongside prior knowledge and experience;
- Use appropriate techniques, apparatus, and materials during laboratory work, paying attention to health and safety;
- Make and record observations using a range of methods for different investigations; and evaluate the reliability of methods and suggest possible improvements;
- Present observations using appropriate methods;
- Interpret observations and identify patterns using those observations to draw conclusions;
- Present reasoned explanations, including explaining data in relation to predictions and hypotheses;
- Learn about the concept of dissolving of metal salts to form silicates.
Potassium aluminium sulfate is of NO SIGNIFICANT HAZARD
Sodium silicate solution is of NO SIGNIFICANT HAZARD (but it is sensible to wear eye protection given its alkaline nature)
Iron aluminium sulphate is a SKIN AND EYE IRRITANT.
Iron(II) sulphate, copper(II) sulphate, and calcium nitrate are IRRITANTS (CATEGORY 2) and Harmful if swallowed (ACUTE TOXINS CATEGORY 4)
Iron(III) chloride and Zinc sulphate are also harmful if swallowed (ACUTE TOXINS CATEGORY 4). Zinc sulphate causes EYE DAMAGE (CATEGORY 1) and iron(III) chloride is CORROSIVE TO SKIN AND EYES (CATEGORY 1B)
Manganese sulphate is a specific target organ toxin on repeated exposure (Category 2) affecting the brain in particular. (The small amount and short potential exposure here suggests that is not an issue.)
Nickel and cobalt compounds are carcinogenic and sensitisers (and more). They should not be used by pupils of this age. If it is required, the teacher can set up a demonstration garden with these,
Eye protection should be worn. Given that the solids are only being handled with forceps, there is no need for gloves; the silicate solution is only an irritant – though pupils with sensitive skin might be better off wearing gloves.
- Eye protection
- Large glass jar with lid (e.g. an empty, cleaned coffee jar)
- Glass rod
- Water glass (about 250 cm3) (Irritant solution)
- Water best to use deionised water but if unavailable tap water will give some effects (about 300 cm3)
- 2 large crystals of the following (see hazard warnings)
- iron (II) sulfate (Harmful & irritant)
- copper (II) sulfate (Harmful & irritant)
- calcium nitrate (Oxidising, harmful & Irritant)
- manganese (II) sulfate (Specific target Organ Toxin on Repeated Exposure & Dangerous for the Environment)
- iron aluminium sulfate (Irritant)
- potassium aluminium sulfate (Low hazard)
- iron (III) chloride (Harmful / Corrosive)
- zinc sulfate (Harmful, Eye Damage & Dangerous for the Environment)
- nickel sulfate (Harmful, Irritant Carcinogen, Mutagen, Reproductive Toxin, Skin sensitiser, Respiratory sensitiser, Specific target Organ Toxin on Repeated Exposure & dangerous for the Environment)
- cobalt chloride (Harmful, Carcinogen, Mutagen, Reproductive Toxin, Skin sensitiser, Respiratory sensitiser, Dangerous for the Environment)
Provide a 8% solution of sodium silicate in water. This works well by producing results both within the lesson and over time. With older students different dilutions could be tried and the results compared
Powders of the chemicals can be used if crystals are unavailable. The powder can be carefully dropped against the side of the jar just above the water line. If any floats on the surface it can be nudged under the water to drop to the bottom of the jar. The powders still produce an interesting array of crystal tendrils.
Label the jar of water glass solution IRRITANT.
Avoid using glass beakers for this practical if you can because the chemicals will be very difficult to clean off the glassware afterwards.
Although many of these chemicals are damaging to the environment, the amounts used are so small as to be not significant. The solution can be washed to waste in the foul water drain with copious quantities of cold water.
A strong water glass solution will grow a crystal formation more quickly than a weak one.
Crystals of chemicals will produce further growths of crystals on the original one over time, chemical powders grow tendrils.
Although cobalt chloride and nickel sulphate produce colourful crystals (magenta/purple and green/blue respectively) a very good and colourful chemical garden can be created with the less toxic chemicals.
The chemical garden chemicals will produce the following colours of crystals (excluding those mentioned above): green, blue, white, orange/brown, brown.
Taking the work further:
Students could experiment with different strength solutions of sodium silicate.
Sodium silicate solution is highly alkaline and therefore it may be best for younger students to only test dilutions of the solution that have already been provided for them.